Giants gave the Dolphins offense fits, but the Phins defense returned the favor
The Miami Dolphins’ offensive line looked considerably different against Washington compared to their last preseason game vs the Commanders. Thursday’s joint practice with the New York Giants provided a much tougher test—and exposed both the progress Miami has made and the work still ahead.
New York brought one of the deepest defensive fronts Miami will see, featuring Brian Burns, Abdul Carter, Kayvon Thibodeaux and Chauncey Golston. The Giants also attacked with frequent blitzes, creating protection problems throughout practice. Miami struggled collectively, with free rushers and pressure making life difficult for Malik Willis.
There were a couple of fight where punches were thrown on both sides. Even some coaches went down to break it up. The biggest issue besides that lack of discipline was that plenty of time was lost. This team needs every rep it can get to get better, and more than a few were wasted.
That doesn’t mean everything up front was bad.
O-line Was Learned? Will they Learn?
Rookie Kayden Proctor had encouraging individual performance, including an impressive rep against Thibodeaux in which his initial punch knocked the veteran backward before Proctor reset and anchored again. Proctor also had some struggles, including a holding penalty that erased a De’Von Achane touchdown, but those growing pains should be expected from a rookie transitioning from tackle to guard.
Jonah Savaiinaea had a more difficult day after an encouraging preseason opener. He won some one-on-ones but lost others, illustrating the difference between facing Washington’s second unit and competing against the Giants’ talented front. Patrick Paul struggled at times as well, although his improved feet and hips remain encouraging. Some of Miami’s problems also appeared to involve awareness and communication against New York’s blitz packages rather than simply losing physically.
you can bet with the best pay per head that the biggest concern remains right tackle.
Austin Jackson reportedly struggled throughout practice, while Caedan Wallace did little to inspire confidence when given opportunities. With Jamaree Salyer already lost, Miami’s lack of proven offensive-line depth is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore. One injury could force a developmental player into an important role before he is ready.
There was better news on defense.
Phins Defense was Down Some Key Players & Still Shined
Miami created problems for the Giants despite practicing without Chop Robinson, Jordyn Brooks, Zach Sieler, and Kenneth Grant. Jacob Rodriguez continued his impressive summer with an interception and another near takeaway, while expanding effectively in zone coverage. Kyle Louis also drew positive reports, and Jordan Phillips was reportedly nearly immovable inside, even when New York attempted to double-team him.
The Dolphins didn’t win the day. That’s okay.
After looking good against Washington’s backups, Miami needed to see what happened when its young offensive line faced legitimate NFL pass-rush talent. The answer was mixed: the talent and physical improvement are visible, but the protection, communication and depth aren’t ready yet.
That’s exactly what August is for.
But let’s hope for a better September.
Go Phins!!!